Profile Major Works Resources

John Elliot Cairnes, 1823-1875

Portrait of J.E. Cairnes

Born in County Louth, Ireland, the son of a brewer, John Elliot Cairnes was educated at Trinity College Dublin.  He acquired his B.A. in 1848 and his M.A. in 1848.  In 1856, Cairnes won an appointment to the the Whately Chair in Political Economy at Trinity College, Dublin, which he would hold until 1861.  In 1859, Cairnes received a joint appointment as professor of jurisprudence at Queen's College Galway, which he would hold until 1870.  From 1866 to 1870, Cairnes was a professor of political economy University College London.  He retired in 1872, due to ill-health.

An ardent disciple and friend of John Stuart Mill, Cairnes is often regarded as "the last of the Classical economists".  It was upon his shoulders that fell the responsibility of defending the Classical Ricardian doctrine in its waning years of 1869-75 -- against Thornton, against Ruskin, against his own disciple Cliffe-Leslie and, finally, against Jevons and the Marginalist Revolution.   

Cairnes's most famous book -- the Whately lectures of 1857 -- was an attempt to outline the future research program for Classical economics.   Decades later, in 1874, Cairnes offered the feeble, last gasp of Classical doctrine, with the wages fund doctrine embarrassingly defended and Jevons's new theory reluctantly reviewed.

Cairnes's shining hour was his widely-discussed 1862 treatise Slave Power.  Cairnes analyzed the consequences of slavery for economic development, in particular how it speeded up soil erosion, discouraged the introduction of technical innovations and stifled commerce and enterprise more generally.  Written during the American Civil War, Cairnes warned British policymakers to think twice about backing the economically-unviable Confederacy.  Cairnes book was instrumental in turning the tide of popular English opinion against the rebels.

Cairnes's 1865 articles on the Irish land question were even more radical.  Arguing that labor was the basis of property in land, Cairnes denounced the attempt to introduce an English-style free market for land in Ireland and to instead encourage peasant-proprietorship via State-controlled land rents.   This radical proposal was taken up by John Stuart Mill in his own book on the Irish question -- and both Cairnes and Mill were met by howls of disapproval by classical liberals in England, who denounced the violation of the "sanctity of free contract".  

Cairnes struck back in a series of 1870 articles in a full-frontal assault on laissez-faire dogmatism, arguing that while it was a "good rule of thumb", but had no "scientific basis" and certainly should not be applied indiscriminately as if it were a religion.  Cairnes took aim particularly at the liberal heroes, Frederic Bastiat and Hebert Spencer, taking them to task for having transformed political economy into a muddled apologist theology. 

 

  


top1.gif (924 bytes)Top

Major Works of John E. Cairnes

  • "On the Best Means of Raising the Supplies for a War Expenditure, read March, 1854", 1854, Papers read before the DSS  [bk]
  • An Examination into the Principles of Currency involved in the Bank Charter Act of 1844, 1854 [bk], [McM]
  • "The Effect of War on Prices", 1856, J of DSS, p.223
  • The Character and Logical Method of Political Economy, 1857 [bk] [1875 2nd. ed]. [McM; lib]
  • "The Laws according to which a depreciation of the precious metals consequent upon an increase of supply takes place, considered in connection with recent Gold Discoveries", 1859, J of Dublin SS
  • "Essays towards an Experimental Solution to the Gold Question", 1859, Fraser's Magazine,
  • "Essay towards a Solution to the Gold Question", 1860, Fraser's Magazine
  • "Review of Chevalier, On the probable fall in the value of gold", 1860, Edinburgh Review
  • The Slave Power: Its Character, Career, and Probable Designs: Being an Attempt to Explain the Real Issues Involved in the American Contest, 1862 [bk], [1862 2nd ed], [moa]
  • The Revolution in America a lecture, 1862 [bk] [1863 7th ed]
  • "Estrangement Between the United States and Great Britain ", 1862, London Anti-Slavery Advocate (repr. Living Age moa)
  • The Southern Confederacy and the African Slave Trade: A correspondence between Prof. Cairnes and Geoge McHenry, 1863 [bk]
  • "Ireland", 1864, Edinburgh Review
  • Notes on the state of Ireland, 1864
  • "Ireland in Transition", 1865, The Economist
  • "The Negro Suffrage", 1865
  • "The "Law" of Demand and Supply", 1866, The Economist
  • "Bastiat", 1870, Fortnightly Review
  • "Political Economy and Land", 1870, Fortnightly Review, p.41
  • "M. Comte and Political Economy", 1870, Fortnightly Review, p.579
  • "A Note (on Harrison)", 1870, Fortnightly Review, p.246
  • "Bastiat", 1870, Fortnightly Review, p.411
  • "Political Economy and Laissez-faire", 1871, Fortnightly Review, p.80
  • "Our Defenses - a National or Standing Army?", 1871, Fortnightly Review, p.167
  • "New Theories of Political Economy", 1872, Fortnightly Review, p.71
  • Essays in Political Economy, Theoretical and applied, 1873. [bk]
  • Political Essays, 1873 [bk]
  • "VII - His Work in Political Economy" 1873, in John Stuart Mill, His life and works: Twelve Sketches, p.65
  • "Froude's Irish History", 1874, Fortnightly Review, p.171
  • Some Leading Principles of Political Economy Newly Expounded , 1874 [bk]
  • "Mr. Spencer on Social Evolution", 1875, Fortnightly Review. p.63
  • "Mr. Spencer on the Study of Sociology", 1875, Fortnightly Review, p.200

HET

 

top1.gif (924 bytes)Top

Resources on John Elliot Cairnes

 

 
top1.gif (924 bytes)Top
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

All rights reserved, Gonçalo L. Fonseca