Profile Major Works Resources

Gen. Francis Amasa Walker, 1840-1897.

Portrait of F.A. Walker

Widely regarded as the "dean" of  American economics.  Francis Amasa Walker was born on June 2, 1840.  His father, the economist  Amasa Walker had settled in Amherst, Massachusetts where Walker was to get his early education.  He acquired his B.A. from Amherst College in 1860 and joined a law firm.  In 1862, when the American Civil War broke out,  Francis Walker volunteered for the Union Army of the Potomac.  His bravery and prowess earned him quick promotions and many wounds.  He was captured by Confederate forces at Petersburg in 1864, but was returned later that year during a prisoner exchange.  In 1865, while still twenty-four, he was brevetted brigadier general.   

After the war, Walker returned to Amherst to teach Greek and Latin at Williston Seminary and Amherst College.  He helped his father prepare his 1866 treatise Science of Wealth and fully absorbed his father's teachings in Classical economics   However, bored by abstraction, Walker left for Washington DC in 1869 in the hopes of starting up a career in journalism.   For a year, he worked under David A. Wells at the Bureau of Statistics at the Treasury.  Walker did such an exceptional job that he was appointed superintendent of the tenth U.S. Census of 1870.  He had just turned thirty. 

Walker's unusually thorough collection, sifting and presentation of the census results (published in 1874 as the Statistical Atlas earned him a well-merited applause from statisticians and scholars everywhere.   In 1871, he worked for a while as Commissioner for Indian Affairs in the Grant administration.  In 1872, Walker was invited by Yale University to replace Daniel Coit Gilman at the Sheffield Scientific School.  Walker was Yale's first professor of political economy.

Walker's stay at Yale, however, was not a very happy one.  Without a Yale B.A. and confined to the Sheffield ghetto, Walker felt very much the outsider there.  His rival at Yale College, the dogmatic conservative economist William Graham Sumner, had the ear of the administration.  Sumner's abrasive personality grated on Walker.  The statistically-minded Walker was kindly disposed towards the "New Generation" of German-trained American economists, whereas Sumner saw them as his enemies.  Perhaps because of this, Walker did not pass up opportunities to absent himself from Yale.  For a time (1877-79), Walker served as visiting professor at the fledgling the Johns Hopkins University, one of the returnees' citadels. In 1878, Walker was the US delegate to the international monetary conference in Paris, and subsequently accepted appointment as the superintendent of the 1880 census.

Francis A. Walker finally resigned from Yale in 1881 to become one of the first presidents of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), presiding over a period of rapid growth of that institution.  Walker was also elected president of the American Statistical Association (ASA) in 1882 and was drafted by the "new generation" economists to became the first president of the American Economic Association (AEA) in 1885. (from 1947, the AEA would award the "Walker Medal" every two years, to prominent economists for their lifetime achievements; this was discontinued after 1977, with the advent of the Nobel Memorial prize.)

Throughout his life, Walker strove to establish the "scientific" status of economics, and was a pioneer in using statistical data to illustrate economic arguments. While not really a "Neoclassical" in the strict sense, Walker nonetheless helped bury Classical economics by his 1875 demolition of the "Wages Fund" doctrine.   This was followed up in his 1876 book, The Wages Question.  Walker went on to develop a unique theory of distribution, which generalized the Ricardian theory of rent to explain the returns to labor, capital and entrepreneurship - -- thereby presaging the marginal productivity theory of distribution.  Walker posited his new theory in an 1887 article in the QJE and challenged critics to tear it down.  This led to a series of polemics in the QJE of 1887-90 with Silas MacVane, Sidney Webb and others taking up the gauntlet.

Avidly courted by both by both American Neoclassicals and the American Institutionalists, Walker cannot readily be classified as either.  Being the son of Amasa Walker, Francis Walker was also particularly interested in currency questions, authored a well-received textbook on money, and became a proponent of bimetallism.  But Walker also grew increasingly conservative with age.  He eventually became an outspoken apologist of the Gilded Age and a formidable opponent of Henry George, socialists, populists and immigration.

 

  


top1.gif (924 bytes)Top

Major works of Francis A. Walker

  • Commerce and Navigation of the United States, 2 vols, 1868-9.
  • "American Industry in the Census", 1869, Atlantic Monthly, p.689 [moa]
  • "What to do with the Surplus", 1870, Atlantic Monthly, p.72 [moa]
  • "The Indian Question", 1873, NAR (Apr), p.329 [moa]
  • "Our Population in 1900", 1873, Atlantic Monthly, p.487 [moa]
  • "Indian Citizenship", 1874, International Review, p.305
  • The Indian Question, 1874 [bk, moa]
  • Statistical Atlas of the United States, 1874.
  •  "The Wage- Fund Theory", 1875, North American Review (Jan) p.84-118 [moa]
  • "Our Domestic Service", 1875, Scribner's, p.273 [moa]
  • "Growth and Distribution of Population", 1875, Harper's, p.391 [moa]
  • The Wages Question: A treatise on wages and the wages class, 1876. [bk], [moa] [Lib]
  • "The Philadelphia Exhibition - the Late World's Fair", 1877, International Review, Pt.1 (p.363) Pt. 2 (p.497), Pt. 3 (p.673)
  • The World's Fair, Philadelphia 1876, a critical account, 1878 [bk]
  • Money, 1878. [bk] [1883 ed]
  • Judge's Reports on Awards, 8 vols, 1878.
  • Money in its Relation to Trade and Industry, 1879. [bk]
  • "Principles of Taxation" 1880, Princeton Review, p.92 [moa]
  • "The Law of Rent in its Relations to the Irish Land Question", 1882, International Review, p.52
  • "The Growth of the United States", 1882, Century, p.920 [moa], plus "Correction" (1883, p.462 moa)
  • "Henry George's Social Fallacies", 1883, NAR, p.147 [moa]
  • "American Manufactures", 1883, Princeton Rev (May), p.213
  • Land and its Rent, 1883. [bk]
  • Political Economy, 1883. [1st ed] [1887 2nd ed; 1888 3rd ed] [Lib]
  • " Shall Silver be Demonetized?", 1885, NAR p.489 [moa] (with Sumner and Laughlin)
  • History of the Second Army Corps in the Army of the Potomac, 1886 [bk]
  • A Plea for Industrial Education in the Public Schools, 1887 [bk]
  • "Socialism", 1887, Scribner's, p.107 [moa]
  • "What Shall We Tell the Working-Classes?", 1887, Scribner's, p.619 [moa]
  • "General Hancock and the Artillery at Gettysburg", 1887, Century, p.803 [moa]
  • "The Source of Business Profits", 1887, QJE, (Apr) p.265-88 [js]
  • "The Eleventh Census of the United States", 1888, QJE (Jan), p.135-61 [js]
  • "The Bases of Taxation", 1888, PSQ (Mar), p.1 [js]
  • "Reply to Mr. MacVane, on the Source of Business Profits", 1888, QJE (Apr), p.263-96 [js]
  • "Efforts of the Manual Labouring Class to Better Their Condition", 1888, Pub AEA (Jul) p.151 [js]
  • Memoir of Hon. Amasa Walker, LL.D., 1888 [bk]
  • "Recent Progress of Political Economy in the United States: Opening Address to Third Annual Meeting of AEA", 1889, Pub AEA (Jul), p.243 (p.17-40) [js]
  • First Lessons in Political Economy, 1889. [bk]
  • "Protection and Protectionists", 1890, QJE, p.245-75 [js]
  • "Mr. Bellamy and the New Nationalist Party", 1890, Atlantic Monthly, p.248 [moa]
  • "The Eight-Hour Law Agitation", 1890, Atlantic Monthly, p.800 [moa]
  •  "The Doctrine of Rent, and the Residual Claimant Theory of Wages", 1891, QJE, p.417-37 [js]
  • "The Tide of Economic Thought", 1891, Pub AEA (Jan-Mar), p.13 [js] (presidential address)
  • "Dr. Boehm-Bawerk's Theory of Interest", 1892, QJE, p.399-416 [js]
  •  "The Value of Money", 1893, QJE, p.62-76 [js]
  • "The Technical School and the University " 1893, Atlantic Monthly, p.390 [moa]
  • "The Free Coinage of Silver", 1893, JPE
  • "The Value of Money", 1894, Pub AEA (Jan), p.49 [js] (discussion by E. Atkinson)
  • General Hancock, 1894 [bk]
  •  "The Quantity Theory of Money", 1895, QJE, p.372-79 [js]
  • The Making of the Nation, 1783-1817. [bk]
  • International Bimetallism, 1896. [bk]
  • "Restriction on Immigration", 1896, Atlantic Monthly, p. 822 [moa]
  • "The Causes of Poverty", 1897, Century, p.210 [moa]
  • Discussions in Education, 1899 [bk]
  • Discussions in Economics and Statistics, 1899.  (D.Dewey, editor), v.1, v.2

HET

 

top1.gif (924 bytes)Top

Resources on Francis A. Walker

Contemporary

  • "Walker's Wages Question", 1877, North American Review (Mar),  p.305 [moa]
  • "Review of Political Economy", 1883, Atlantic Monthly [moa]
  • "Review of Land and its Rent", 1884, New Englander and Yale Review [moa]
  • QJE debate on Walker's theory of distribution:
    • Apr 1887: F.A. Walker: "The Source of Business Profits", 1887, QJE, p.265-88 [js] (original challenge)
    • July 1887: Alfred Marshall "The Theory of Business Profits" p.477-81 [js] (reply to Walker)
    • Oct 1887: Silas MacVane "The Theory of Business Profits", 1887, QJE, p.1-36 [js] (reply to Walker and Marshall)
    • Jan 1888 Sidney Webb: "The Rate of Interest and the Laws of Distribution", p.188-208 [js] (reply to Walker)
    • Jan 1888 Alfred Marshall "Wages and Profits", p.218-23 [js]  (reply to MacVane)
    • Apr 1888 F.A. Walker "Reply to Mr. MacVane, on the Source of Business Profits", p.263-96 [js] (reply to MacVane)
    • Jul 1888 Silas MacVane:  "Business Profits and Wages: a rejoinder", 1888, QJE, p.453-68 [js] (reply to Walker)
    • July 1888  Sidney Webb: "The Rate of Interest", p.469-72 [js]  (on Walker)
    • Oct 1888 Alfred Marshall "Letter on Business Profits", p.109 [js]  (complaint to QJE about MacVane)
    • Oct 1889 Simon Nelson Patten:  "President Walker's Theory of Distribution", p.34-49 [js] (on Walker)
    • Jul 1890 Frederick B. Hawley: "Profits and the Residual Theory", p.387-96 [js]  (on Walker)
    • Jan 1891  James Bonar "The Value of Labor in Relation to Economic Theory", p.137-64 [js] (expand on Walker)
    • Apr 1891 John A. Hobson: "The Law of the Three Rents", p.263-88 [js] (expand on Walker)
    • Apr 1891: John Bates Clark "Distribution as Determined by a Law of Rent", p.289-318 [js] (expand on Walker)
    • Apr 1891: C.E. Collet  "Wages and the Standard of Living: Comment on Bonar", p.365-69 [js] (query to Bonar)
    • July 1891: F.A. Walker "The Doctrine of Rent, and the Residual Claimant Theory of Wages", p.417-37 [js]  (reply to Bonar, Hobson and Clark)
    • Oct 1891 J. Bonar "The Residual Theory of Distribution", p.105-07 [js] (reply to Walker)
    • Oct 1891: J.B. Clark "The Statics and Dynamics of Distribution", p.111-19 [js] (reply to Walker)
  • E. v. Böhm-Bawerk: "The Positive Theory of Capital and its Critics: Part II - General Walker against Capital and Interest", 1895, QJE (Apr), p.235-56 [js]
  • Note on Walker's death in QJE, 1897 (Jan)  p.210.
  • "In Memoriam. Francis Amasa Walker", by Roland P. Falkner, 1897, AAPSS (Mar) p.1 [js]
  • "The Career of Francis Amasa Walker", by C.F. Dunbar, 1897, QJE, (Jul), p.437-48 [js]
  • "Francis Amasa Walker" by Carroll D. Wright, 1897, Pub of ASA, (Jun), p.245-75
  • "Bibliography of the Writings and Reported Addresses of Francis Amasa Walker", 1897 Pub of ASA, (Jun) p.276 [p]
  • "Francis Amasa Walker" and "Bibliography of F.A. Walker's Works", by J.L. Laughlin, 1897, JPE
  • "Review of Walker's Discussions" by H.C. Adams, 1900, JPE
  • Memoir of Francis Amasa Walker, by Francis C. Lowell 1900 [bk]
  • "Review of University of Halle dissertation on F.A. Walker", by W.C. Mitchell 1900, JPE
  • "Biographical Memoir of Francis Amasa Walker, 1840-1897" by John S. Billings, 1902, NAS [pdf]
  • "Walker, Francis Amasa" in R.H. Inglis Palgrave, editor, 1894-1899, Dictionary of Political Economy [1918 ed.]
  • "Walker, Francis Amasa" in J. Conrad et al, (1891-94) Handwörterbuch der Staatswissenschaften [2nd ed, 1898-1901]
  • "Walker, Francis Amasa" in 1911 Encyclopaedia Britannica
  • "Walker, Francis Amasa", 1895, National Cyclopaedia of American Biography, v.5

Modern

 

 
top1.gif (924 bytes)Top
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

All rights reserved, Gonçalo L. Fonseca